Should Notebook Computers Replace Textbooks?


Published on September 25th, 2018

Today, one of the most discussed topics in the educational sphere is the equipping of schools with notebook computers and other devices for studying.

This idea has both supporters and opponents. Let’s figure out all the pros and cons of the innovation.


1. Unloading For The Back



Backpack of 5-grade school child weighs about 8 kg. For comparison, an American special service soldier carries 13 kg. If all books will be stored on one device, then there will be no need to bring “wastepaper” to school. Doctors are positive about the possible “death” of a heavy backpack.

When a child wears it, the load influences the abdominal muscles, while the muscles of the back relax. Such imbalance contributes to the development of kyphosis.


2. Education Becomes More Convenient And Interesting


Using notebook computers increases the motivation for learning. Pupils willingly pass small screening tests, watch educational videos or presentations in order to better understand the material.

The abundance of bright pictures and musical accompaniment turns lessons into an exciting adventure.

In addition, teachers can show the creative talents by inventing ways to use the notebooks in the class. For example, when studying the life and heritage of a certain writer, small video tours to the city where he was born may be used.

If a literary work is considered at the lesson, pedagogue can make a video clip with footage from the screen version.
It is very convenient to create academic papers on the computer.

Previously, it was necessary to write by hand or print the text to hand it over to the teacher, but now, it is enough to send an e-mail.


3. More Information



Electronic devices provide much more information than conventional sources. If all schools connect to a single free Internet network, students will be able to access extensive databases on the subjects they are interested in.

They already do it in their homes. Today, it is necessary to spend just a few minutes to find useful information or reliable college paper writing service.


4. Knowledge Control


Having received the password for the “cloud”, parents will be able to see the marks of their children. Pupils do not always tell about bad results, but parents’ meetings every 1-1.5 months are not enough to have an objective picture of their academic performance.

And it’s not even about a parental desire to control children. Just if they will have serious problems in their studies, it may be too late to help them deal with the difficulties.

Also, on his computer, the teacher must control what the children do on their devices.


5. Saving Time

Saving Time

A teacher can upload a small test for assessing the homework to the pupils’ notebooks and turn on a timer that automatically blocks the actions of the child when the time is up.

At the touch of a button, all the tests come to the teacher’s computer, the “machine” processes the answers and, within minutes, the scores appear on the screens. In such a way, the time is saved for both teachers and students.

Another useful option is consideration of the statistics. It allows determining, for example, which of the questions had the greatest number of errors in answers, where are the weakest places of the student (or even the teacher).

This instrument is very helpful in pedagogical work. It immediately becomes clear on what training points it is worth dwelling in more detail.


6. Less Money For Additional Literature

Less Money For Additional Literature

Even teachers complain that the current school textbooks on some subjects leave much to be desired. For example, the “dead” vocabulary is used in the textbooks on foreign languages.

Therefore, pedagogues offer parents to purchase additional textbooks, as a rule, not cheap. If electronic school materials will be created and placed in the free access, spending on notebook computers will be justified.


7. Teacher’s Authority Increases

Less Money For Additional Literature

In the pedagogical environment, many people say: “We need to keep up with the time in order to keep up with our students.”

The teacher who does not use all the possibilities of technical means in the process of teaching partly loses his authority in the eyes of the pupils, being in a worse position compared with the technologically advanced schoolchildren.

The innovations will allow the student and teacher to get closer, to be on the same wave.
Students themselves agree with this opinion. “When I talk about what I read on the Internet at the lesson, sometimes, this information is new for my teacher.

I would like educators to be more modern, to use the Internet and not limit themselves to expounding the outdated material,” – the student of one of the US schools complained.

The leadership of each school should make sure that notebooks are introduced in class. Modern devices can stay covered with dust on the shelves: many teachers are conservative.

1.  A Blow Against The Family Budget


Parents are concerned that innovations will result in serious expenditure. For some families, even a loan for the purchase of a technical device may prove to be an unbearable burden. In addition, if the computer breaks, it will have to be repaired.


2. Security


“My son was robbed on the way home from school. He lost the old mobile phone, which was already almost broken. I do not understand why the thief needed it.

And what will happen if the student has a modern notebook computer, more attractive target, in his backpack?” – the dad of one of schoolboys worries.

Police agrees that, of course, the risk that a child can be robbed increases. Therefore, parents need to explain to pupils that they should not use the device in a crowded place.

In addition, it is best to carry it in an ordinary backpack, and not in a special bag, so that nothing indicates the presence of a computer.


3. Damage For Eyes


When a person works with a notebook for a long time, muscles do not relax, there is a spasm, which can result in the nearsightedness.

And the smaller the screen size, the more likely it is to spoil the eyesight. Therefore, the developers should create the program which will turn the device off or block it, for example, for 5-10 minutes every 45-50 minutes.