Published on March 20th, 2025
Instagram Experiments With AI-Generated Comments: Is This the Future of Social Media?
Social media has always been about human connection—engaging conversations, exchanging opinions, and sharing experiences. But Instagram’s latest experiment with AI-generated comments is raising some eyebrows.
Is this innovation a game-changer for engagement, or just another step towards making social platforms feel less human?
What’s Happening?
Instagram is reportedly testing AI-generated comments on posts, as spotted by app researcher Jonah Manzano.
Some users are now seeing a “pencil with a star” icon next to the comment field. When tapped, it generates a list of possible comments that users can post on an image or video.
Essentially, this means you no longer need to think about what to say. Meta’s AI can craft a response for you, removing the need for originality, personal thought, or even basic communication skills.
Read More: Instagram’s “Edits” App
Meta’s Push for AI-Powered Interactions
This experiment is part of Meta’s broader strategy to integrate AI into its platforms.
The company is also developing AI-powered chatbot versions of users that can interact with others based on predefined personality traits and response styles.
The logic behind these AI-generated interactions is simple: the more engagement on a post, the better the visibility and interaction metrics.
If AI-generated comments can make posts look livelier, they might encourage real users to join the conversation.
The Big Question: Is This a Good Idea?
While automation has its perks—think Gmail’s smart replies or LinkedIn’s AI-generated comments—there’s a fine line between enhancing engagement and stripping social media of its authenticity.
Unlike auto-suggested responses, Instagram’s AI-generated comments are designed to be more context-specific, making them seem more relevant to the content. But are they really fostering meaningful conversations?
Here’s what AI-generated comments could mean for Instagram’s future:
- More Interaction, Less Authenticity
AI-generated comments might make posts appear more popular, but at what cost? If conversations are driven by bots rather than humans, the social experience becomes diluted. - A Boost for Influencers and Brands?
For businesses and influencers, AI-generated comments could make engagement appear higher. But if real users suspect they’re interacting with bots rather than actual followers, it could hurt trust and credibility. - The Rise of AI Bots as “Users”
Meta has been exploring AI-driven profiles that mimic human behavior. If AI-generated comments are part of this vision, we might see a future where AI bots are indistinguishable from real users.
You May Also Like: Threads Unveils ‘Media’ Tab & Photo Tagging for Better UX
What Does This Mean for Social Media?
The big picture here is whether AI-driven engagement actually makes platforms more engaging or just more artificial. Social media thrives on human connection.
If AI-generated comments become widespread, users might find themselves interacting with platforms that feel less genuine and more automated.
While AI can be a great tool for assisting with communication, it shouldn’t replace real human interaction.
Whether Meta’s experiment will be a success or a misstep remains to be seen. But one thing is certain—if social platforms prioritize artificial engagement over real conversations, they risk losing the very essence of what makes them “social.”
Would you use AI-generated comments on your Instagram posts? Let’s discuss in the comments—human ones preferred!
